Hybrid bus experience
Sorry I just posted the first link that showed up, not the most current. As of mid-2006:
"...Through these projects and others, Eaton has built a business case for their hybrid electric powertrain that has thus far resulted in a recent order of 75 additional Opti-Fleet E-700 trucks that are currently being placed into service in FedEx Express's pick-up and delivery fleet along with orders from UPS for 50 additional hybrid step-van delivery vehicles to be placed into service in late 2006."
http://www.theautochannel.com/news/2...22/012360.html
And from a big meeting on the subject last November:
"...The parcel group is in the midst of organizing a joint purchase of more than 20 pre-production hybrid hydraulic parcel trucks;
The refuse group is refining a purchase commitment for 15-20 pre-production hybrid refuse trucks; and
The utility group is looking to expand fleet participation to include other applications that use similar truck sizes, and is putting together plans for a potential 500-1000 truck joint "order" if appropriate price points, business case, performance data and purchase cost assistance can be achieved. "
http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...ing_report.php
CalStart/Westart's timeline:
http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...02006%20Dr.pdf
None of these answer the question "how many hybrid trucks are on the road right now?" so I emailed that Q to Monica Alvarez, a Westart project manager. Will let y'all know if anything interesting in reply.
DAS
"...Through these projects and others, Eaton has built a business case for their hybrid electric powertrain that has thus far resulted in a recent order of 75 additional Opti-Fleet E-700 trucks that are currently being placed into service in FedEx Express's pick-up and delivery fleet along with orders from UPS for 50 additional hybrid step-van delivery vehicles to be placed into service in late 2006."
http://www.theautochannel.com/news/2...22/012360.html
And from a big meeting on the subject last November:
"...The parcel group is in the midst of organizing a joint purchase of more than 20 pre-production hybrid hydraulic parcel trucks;
The refuse group is refining a purchase commitment for 15-20 pre-production hybrid refuse trucks; and
The utility group is looking to expand fleet participation to include other applications that use similar truck sizes, and is putting together plans for a potential 500-1000 truck joint "order" if appropriate price points, business case, performance data and purchase cost assistance can be achieved. "
http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...ing_report.php
CalStart/Westart's timeline:
http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...02006%20Dr.pdf
None of these answer the question "how many hybrid trucks are on the road right now?" so I emailed that Q to Monica Alvarez, a Westart project manager. Will let y'all know if anything interesting in reply.
DAS
Thanks for the links- they were very interesting. According to your last link, the (somewhat outdated, as you say) claims are that FedEx has 18 on the roads in 2005, with plans to add 75 more by May '06 and another 75 'next year', which I suppose may mean by May '07. Assuming that's right, that's 168, as of about three months from now. Not too shabby! By all means, let's get more updated data, though.
But my main point, about how ten or a hundred or so (order of magnitude) is a drop in the bucket next to 100,000++ vehicles in their fleet, still stands. That's about 0.001th of the total, as an order of magnitude approximation. Hard to get tremendously excited about 0.001th. But like I said- it's a step in the right direction.
The thing that I found most exciting in the links you posted was the following:
From http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...02006%20Dr.pdf :
Isn't that fabulous? I wish I knew bunches of people who worked in city transit systems so I could tell them about this change in the law, though I imagine it must be fairly well known by now. NO HYBRID PREMIUM for buses! This is great news and a wonderful policy.
But my main point, about how ten or a hundred or so (order of magnitude) is a drop in the bucket next to 100,000++ vehicles in their fleet, still stands. That's about 0.001th of the total, as an order of magnitude approximation. Hard to get tremendously excited about 0.001th. But like I said- it's a step in the right direction.
The thing that I found most exciting in the links you posted was the following:
From http://www.calstart.org/programs/htu...02006%20Dr.pdf :
The Federal Transit Administration (FTA), which
provides transit bus funding, announced at the Clean Heavy-Duty Vehicle
Conference that they would now be picking up 100% of the incremental cost of a
hybrid bus (this is on top of the 80% share the federal government already pays
for buying transit buses). Transit sized hybrids (40-foot and larger) have now
reached multi-hundred buses actually deployed with orders for about a thousand
more. Our rough count shows somewhere between 1500-2000 units deployed or
on order.
provides transit bus funding, announced at the Clean Heavy-Duty Vehicle
Conference that they would now be picking up 100% of the incremental cost of a
hybrid bus (this is on top of the 80% share the federal government already pays
for buying transit buses). Transit sized hybrids (40-foot and larger) have now
reached multi-hundred buses actually deployed with orders for about a thousand
more. Our rough count shows somewhere between 1500-2000 units deployed or
on order.
Last edited by leahbeatle; Mar 1, 2007 at 01:12 PM.
But how many vehicle do they add each year and how many do they retire each year. If they add say, 1000 vehilces each year and of that 1000, 75 are hybrid, then they are approaching 1% hybrid vehilces in the fleet. That would be a good thing. And before you say they should be doing better, they are a company that MUST be profitable and the hybrids are still in the experimental phase. They don't know the true long term cost of implementing these vehicles, and a guarded stance is to be expected.
I'm glad to see that hybrid buses are delivering results. When I first started posting to this site and mentioned that GM 2-Mode hybrid technology was based on the technology that was being put into a hybrid bus system, several folks on this site poo-pooed the idea that the bus hybrids would ever deliver positive results.
I don't know if the Indy buses are GM installations or another company, but at least they show that there is a lot of poential in converting city bus fleets to hybrid systems.
Peace,
Martin
I don't know if the Indy buses are GM installations or another company, but at least they show that there is a lot of poential in converting city bus fleets to hybrid systems.
Peace,
Martin
Hi Martin,
I didn't have the numbers and I believe you helped us find out there are over 500 out there. This is not something talked about much, any idea about how many have been made and put in service?
One humble request, if you learn of a good technical paper or illustrated break-out chart and paper, I'd be interested in learning more about the 2-Mode system. The available photos and light-weight discussions aren't very detailed. I figured when the Canadian plant began rolling them out, a lot more information would become available. But if something shows up early, I'm 'all ears.'
Thanks,
Bob Wilson
. . . When I first started posting to this site and mentioned that GM 2-Mode hybrid technology was based on the technology that was being put into a hybrid bus system, several folks on this site poo-pooed the idea that the bus hybrids would ever deliver positive results.
. . .
. . .
One humble request, if you learn of a good technical paper or illustrated break-out chart and paper, I'd be interested in learning more about the 2-Mode system. The available photos and light-weight discussions aren't very detailed. I figured when the Canadian plant began rolling them out, a lot more information would become available. But if something shows up early, I'm 'all ears.'
Thanks,
Bob Wilson
Bob Wilson
90% emissions improvements and 30-55% fuel efficiency improvements (70ish% with the system that approximates a plug-in)! That's pretty impressive. Though the buses could have been in really bad shape to begin with, of course- but then it's even better that they're being upgraded. It seems to me like this is some low-hanging fruit, here- lots of room for early and swift improvement!
From Green Car Congress:
http://www.greencarcongress.com/2006...brid_buse.html
"NYC Hybrid Buses Improve Fuel Economy 45% Over Diesel, 100% over CNG"
And for the Prius folks:
From PC Mag:
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1902185,00.asp
"Imagine a transit bus that's as good for the environment as 15,000 Toyota Priuses....."
We've been enjoying the benefits here in NYC at $500,000 a pop.
http://www.greencarcongress.com/2006...brid_buse.html
"NYC Hybrid Buses Improve Fuel Economy 45% Over Diesel, 100% over CNG"
And for the Prius folks:
From PC Mag:
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1902185,00.asp
"Imagine a transit bus that's as good for the environment as 15,000 Toyota Priuses....."
We've been enjoying the benefits here in NYC at $500,000 a pop.
Thanks for the links, Fred! I was suprised by how poorly the natural gas buses did in that study, though I haven't researched them. Also, I'm a little annoyed that they released all these results without including the summer months in the data, because that adds a lot of unnecessary speculation and error bars and lets them natter on about how heat prevents regenerative braking (sounds ridiculous to me from my experience, though if there's an actual engineer here who would back up that assertion and give reasons for it, then of course I'm happy to be convinced).
Still, the winter data is darn impressive, as Fred already pointed out- a 45% improvement!!!! Can you imagine if they cut the fuel usage of the entire NYC bus system by 45%? That would be HUGE.
Still, the winter data is darn impressive, as Fred already pointed out- a 45% improvement!!!! Can you imagine if they cut the fuel usage of the entire NYC bus system by 45%? That would be HUGE.



