The VW that out-sips a Prius
#1
03-13-2008, 02:33 PM
Site Founder
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 4,623
The VW that out-sips a Prius
One of the less pie-in-the-sky concepts of this year’s Geneva International Motor Show (although the Rinspeed sQuba car was rather cool) is this VW Golf TDI Hybrid.
This version of the Golf (a model known as the Rabbit over here) uses an electric motor system similar to that of the Toyota Prius but mates that to a clean and frugal 1.2-liter, three-cylinder diesel-powered engine. Bottom line, in a European fuel economy test cycle, the Prius achieves 54 miles per gallon. This VW could get 69, an improvement of about 28%.
This version of the Golf (a model known as the Rabbit over here) uses an electric motor system similar to that of the Toyota Prius but mates that to a clean and frugal 1.2-liter, three-cylinder diesel-powered engine. Bottom line, in a European fuel economy test cycle, the Prius achieves 54 miles per gallon. This VW could get 69, an improvement of about 28%.
#3
03-15-2008, 03:51 PM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 13
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
It's too bad the cost of diesel around here is $4.00 a gallon, and gas is only $3.16. That about evens things out, you get 28% better mileage and it costs you 26% more to buy the diesel. Maybe the VW will have better performance than the Prius.
It's just my opinion, but I still don't have a good opinion of diesels, past diesels have left a bad taste in my mouth. I admit new ones are much better with the direct injection and cleaner emissions. Unfortunately I've heard the newest diesels are just pumping all that soot that used to go out the exhaust into the engine oil instead. That's better for the environment, but I don't know if it helps your engine. I know one guy who has placed an extra filtration system on his pickup to extend the life of his engine and synthetic oil.
It's just my opinion, but I still don't have a good opinion of diesels, past diesels have left a bad taste in my mouth. I admit new ones are much better with the direct injection and cleaner emissions. Unfortunately I've heard the newest diesels are just pumping all that soot that used to go out the exhaust into the engine oil instead. That's better for the environment, but I don't know if it helps your engine. I know one guy who has placed an extra filtration system on his pickup to extend the life of his engine and synthetic oil.
Last edited by jamnpb; 03-15-2008 at 03:54 PM.
#4
03-15-2008, 09:26 PM
Active Enthusiast
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Bay Area, CA
Posts: 137
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
Would be nice to get a hybrid with some of that lovely German design. Wife says she'd replace her Beetle for one of those (as long as the price isn't too steep.) Too bad I don't expect them to release the beast any time in the near future...
Last edited by leoashton; 03-15-2008 at 09:29 PM.
#5
03-22-2008, 04:14 AM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 15
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
Apologies for resurrecting this old thread, but I think you may be in luck here - from the various descriptions I've read about this VW, I think it will be in EV-only mode as long as it is a short trip (under 7 miles), speed is low, battery is fully charged, and engine load is low.
Can anyone confirm?
-- Edit:
http://www.theautochannel.com/news/2...04/079598.html
... In practice the electric motor powers the vehicle from standstill with the diesel engine only engaging should additional acceleration be required or at higher speeds. ...
... In this respect, it is very like a Honda hybrid system, but the Golf has an electrically operated clutch between the engine and the motor, which, according to Hofmann, allows the Golf to drive on electric power only.
...
The electric-motor clutch system works well and unobtrusively, and electric-only cruising is possible up to about 30mph as long as you are light with the accelerator. "It's for electric rolling, not electric driving," says Hofmann, who adds that as long as the driving requirement is less than 30lb ft and the battery is well charged, the system will not start the engine.
...
...
The electric-motor clutch system works well and unobtrusively, and electric-only cruising is possible up to about 30mph as long as you are light with the accelerator. "It's for electric rolling, not electric driving," says Hofmann, who adds that as long as the driving requirement is less than 30lb ft and the battery is well charged, the system will not start the engine.
...
Last edited by MikeMarsUK; 03-22-2008 at 02:17 PM.
#6
03-23-2008, 06:56 AM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 2
How about the cost of diesel?
Yes its true that the VW Diesel Hybrid will be more fuel efficient than the Prius Hybrid, but keep in mind that the cost of diesel fuel is roughly $.75/gal more than regular unleaded. In simple math, that means the Prius will cost roughly 14.75 cents per mile, while the VW will clock in at 17.25 cents per mile. The Prius is still a proven vehicle with a great track record, and still cheaper to operate.
#7
03-23-2008, 05:35 PM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 15
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
54 mpg (us gallons) vs. 69 mpg (us gallons) gives 27% more miles per gallon for the VW hybrid ... what is the difference between your petrol prices and diesel prices in percentage terms? Will this discrepancy still exist in the summer when heating-oil isn't being sold?
(I am not familiar with the pricing in the USA. In the UK the difference is currently about 5-6%, $8.08 vs. $8.61 per us gallon. Obviously I'm primarily interested in the running costs in my own area :-) ).
Using the MPG figures from the article, but UK fuel prices:
Prius at 54 us mpg, $ 8.08 / us gallon = 14.9 cents per mile
VW hybrid at 69 us mpg, $ 8.61 / us gallon = 12.5 cents per mile
In the UK I calculate the following fuel costs per mile:
The prius official imperial MPG figure is 65.7 mpg (DirectGOV.gov.uk: Official UK figures)
Prius at 65.7 imperial mpg, 106.9 pence / litre = 485 pence / imperial gallon = 7.4 pence per mile
VW hybrid at 83.9 imperial mpg, 113.9 pence / litre = 517 pence / imperial gallon = 6.2 pence per mile
I'm not sure how you're calculating your figures, both the Prius and VW figures look too high since I think your fuel is a lot cheaper than ours?
Last edited by MikeMarsUK; 03-24-2008 at 08:41 AM.
#8
03-24-2008, 09:00 AM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 2
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
Are fuel prices are currently at $3.23 per gallon for regular unleaded, and $3.99 per gallon for diesel. Diesel prices seem to be always about $.75 more per gallon, due to the large amounts of trucks and farming equipment in our state.
#9
03-24-2008, 09:45 AM
Enthusiast
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 15
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
OK, thanks for that, wish our fuel was that cheap :-) !!
In that case, I calculate the following per mile (using mpg figures from the article):
Prius at 54 us mpg, 323 cents per gallon
... hence 323/54 = 5.98 cents per mile
VW hybrid at 69 us mpg, 399 cents per gallon
... hence 399/69 = 5.78 cents per mile
Hence the diesel hybrid is very slightly cheaper per mile than the petrol hybrid under your current fuel costs. But not enough to make a practical difference ($48 / year for a 24k/y mile driver). Of course if the diesel price drops during the summer when heating oil isn't in demand, then it may be more worthwhile.
In that case, I calculate the following per mile (using mpg figures from the article):
Prius at 54 us mpg, 323 cents per gallon
... hence 323/54 = 5.98 cents per mile
VW hybrid at 69 us mpg, 399 cents per gallon
... hence 399/69 = 5.78 cents per mile
Hence the diesel hybrid is very slightly cheaper per mile than the petrol hybrid under your current fuel costs. But not enough to make a practical difference ($48 / year for a 24k/y mile driver). Of course if the diesel price drops during the summer when heating oil isn't in demand, then it may be more worthwhile.
#10
03-25-2008, 09:12 PM
Pretty Darn Active Enthusiast
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 467
Re: The VW that out-sips a Prius
If we are to assume that the majority of Green-Hybrid viewers are from North America, then they should be wary of European test cycles with diesel. For now, the European diesel emissions standards are relatively lax. In order to sell diesel engines on light duty vehicles in North America, they will have to come with supplementary emission-treatment systems, one of which includes injecting AdBlue to the exhaust. These will inevitably affect the fuel efficiency and increase the running costs (ie. less-periodic AdBlue refills).
